Those squiggly exercise curves? Let’s talk. 👀🚶♂️🚴♀️🏋️♀️
bmjmedicine.bmj.com/content/5/1/e001513
Physical activity types, variety, and mortality: results from two prospective cohort studies
A large new study examined the types of physical activity, variety, and mortality over decades of follow-up. The headlines are mostly solid… but some of the graphs deserve a raised eyebrow.
The clear wins
• Being physically active is linked to lower mortality across most activities
• Doing more than one type of activity adds benefit. Variety matters
• Walking shows the most consistent and robust relationship with lower mortality
• Resistance exercise is associated with lower mortality, too, with benefits appearing at relatively modest weekly doses
Where caution is needed
Some dose–response curves look strange. Cycling is a good example. The curve can look “W-shaped”. A little helps, a bit more harms, and then a lot helps again.
Does that make biological sense? Unlikely.
When most...