The Butler Eagle has celebrated its top male and female athletes of the school year each of the past two summers. This time, we are announcing our nominees for the honors and letting readers and fans vote for who they think is the best of the best in Butler County high school athletics. The female 2025-26 AOTY nominees are out now, with the male nominees released Monday. Fans will have a week to vote in the polls at the end of the nomination lists. We’ll announce the fan-vote winners after polls close. Meet the Butler Eagle Female Athlete of the Year nominees: Click the link in bio. #femaleathleteoftheyear #butlercountypa #nominees #vote karnscitygbb