Should Tanner Bibee start Game 1 of the playoffs for the Cleveland Guardians? Cade Cracas makes the case—and Jack O’Rourke isn’t convinced. Cade joins BIGPLAY Cleveland to explain why he would trust Bibee with a potential postseason opener over Gavin Williams and Parker Messick. Jack pushes back on Bibee’s home run risk and questions whether Cleveland should lean on its more consistent options. The panel also builds a potential Guardians playoff lineup, discussing where Steven Kwan, Travis Bazzana, José Ramírez and Chase DeLauter should hit—and how Angel Martínez could fit into the mix. If the Guardians get in, who gets the ball in Game 1: Bibee, Williams or Messick? Make your case in the comments. Subscribe to BIGPLAY Cleveland for Guardians coverage, interviews and Cleveland sports debate. #Guardians #TannerBibee #ClevelandGuardians